Guide
Industrial gear repair and gearbox rebuilds: cost and lead time
Updated
On an industrial unit the repair price is rarely the number that matters. Lead time is, because the line is stopped while you wait.
What a specialist is actually pricing
- Strip, clean and inspect. Dismantle to component level, clean, measure and report. Chargeable, and normally credited against the rebuild if you proceed.
- Wear parts. Bearings, seals, gaskets, circlips and shims. On a current-production unit these are stock items; on an obsolete one they may not be.
- Gears. Inspection for pitting, spalling and tooth damage. Replacement gears may be available, may be pattern, or may have to be cut to order from the old ones.
- Machining. Line boring or sleeving worn bearing housings, building up and regrinding shafts, skimming mating faces, crack repair or welding a damaged case.
- Rebuild, set-up and test. Backlash, preload and end float set to spec, then a run test with noise and temperature checked under load.
- Paint, protect and paperwork. Finish, preservation for storage, and the report and warranty documentation you keep on file.
Industrial gearbox rebuild or refurbishment
Firms use the two words loosely, so ask what each one covers. A rebuild usually means the full job above: strip to component level, renew every bearing and seal, machine what is worn, set up and run test.
A refurbishment is sometimes the same thing and sometimes a lighter clean, reseal and repaint of a unit still sound inside. Whichever word is on it, the quote should list the parts renewed and the test run on the way out.
Gears repair and gear manufacturing
A damaged gear is rarely repaired in place. Light pitting on a lightly loaded gear may be dressed and the gear reused. Anything worse means a replacement from the maker, a pattern gear, or a new gear cut from the old one or from drawings.
Firms that advertise industrial gearbox repair and gear manufacturing do the cutting in house. Otherwise that part of an obsolete rebuild goes out to a gear cutter, and it sets the lead time.
Shaft-mounted gearbox repairs and gearbox shaft repair
Shaft-mounted units hang on the driven shaft with a torque arm. So a worn hollow output bore, a damaged keyway or a failed bush is a common repair alongside the bearings.
A worn solid shaft can be built up by metal spraying or welding and reground to size, or a new shaft made from the old one. Which is cheaper depends on the shaft and the material, so ask for both prices once the strip has measured it.
Where lead time comes from
| Item | Effect on lead time |
|---|---|
| Stock bearings and seals | Little or none; usually next day |
| Standard replacement gears from the maker | Days to weeks, depending on the maker and the ratio |
| Gears cut to order | Weeks, and the single biggest driver on obsolete units |
| Housing line boring or sleeving | Adds machine shop time, and competes for the same machines as other jobs |
| Shaft building up and regrinding | Similar; specialist process, often subcontracted |
| Casing crack repair | Variable, and sometimes the point at which a replacement case is the better answer |
| Exchange unit off the shelf | Shortest by a distance, where one exists for your drive |
Get the nameplate before you ring anybody
Maker, type, ratio, serial number and, if it is there, the mounting arrangement and input power. Photograph the plate and the unit in situ, including the couplings and how it is mounted. A specialist can check parts availability from a plate in minutes, and that check is the difference between a useful price and a shrug.
If the plate is gone, good photographs of the casing, the shaft ends and the mounting feet will often let an experienced firm identify it anyway.
Signs of a faulty industrial gearbox
Rising noise or a new whine, higher running temperature, oil leaks at the seals, metal in the oil or on the drain plug magnet, and vibration that grows over weeks.
Bearings are the commonest single cause where a large population of gearbox damage has been recorded. The US Department of Energy reports that 76% of wind turbine gearbox failures in its database are caused by the bearings (US Department of Energy).
That population is wind turbines, not UK plant. But it is why an early oil sample or vibration reading often turns a rebuild into a bearing change.
Industrial gearbox service
Between failures, a service is an oil change to the grade and interval on the plate, and a check for leaks, breather condition, coupling alignment and mounting bolts. Where the drive is critical, add an oil analysis or vibration reading on a schedule. Most repair firms will quote it as a contract.
It is cheaper than any rebuild, and it is the evidence that the PUWER maintenance duty below has been met.
Downtime is the real number
Work out what an hour of that line being down costs, then price the options against it. A more expensive exchange unit that gets you running on Thursday can be dramatically cheaper than a rebuild that gets you running the following month.
The other side of the same coin is planning. A spare unit on the shelf, or a rebuilt swap-out held for a critical drive, converts a crisis into a scheduled job.
That is also the cheapest way to comply with the maintenance duty. HSE guidance on PUWER requires work equipment to be maintained in an efficient state, in efficient order and in good repair (HSE).
If the drive is part of lifting equipment, a crane, hoist or winch, it also falls under LOLER as well as PUWER, and thorough examination requirements apply (HSE). Tell the specialist up front, because the paperwork on the way out is different.